Survivor Stories

The following accounts represent firsthand testimonies from individuals who experienced the institutional culture at Petra Bible Church. Names have been changed to protect identities. The stories are presented as received, with minimal editing for clarity.

Estimated read time: 20 minutes|5 testimonies

Content Warning: The accounts on this page contain descriptions of institutional manipulation, financial misconduct, coercive membership practices, and references to international criminal activity. Some details may be disturbing. Reader discretion is advised.

01

"Sarah"

Former Member, 2018–2021

I started attending Petra Bible Church in the fall of 2018 because a coworker invited me. At first, it seemed like any other church. The worship was fine. People were friendly enough. But within the first few weeks, I started noticing small things. Certain people would stop talking when I walked by. Groups at coffee hour would close ranks when an outsider approached. There was a clear inner circle, and I was not in it.

The sermons themselves had a controlling quality that I could not quite articulate at first. It was not overt. Jared never said anything that would set off immediate alarm bells. But there was a persistent undercurrent of "if you truly love God, you will submit to this church's authority." The word "submit" came up a lot. Submit to the elders. Submit to the structure. Submit to the process. I remember thinking, what process? Nobody had explained any process to me.

After about six months, I was told I could begin the membership pathway. I was relieved, honestly. I thought being a member might mean I would finally understand what everyone was whispering about. The first two tiers were normal enough. Tier one was a class on the church's statement of faith. Tier two was a meeting with an elder where they asked about my spiritual history and whether I had any unresolved conflicts with other members. Standard stuff, or so I thought.

Tier three was different. I was told to arrive at the church on a Wednesday evening at 9 PM. When I got there, the parking lot was dark except for a few cars parked around back. I was led through a side entrance I had never noticed before and down a staircase to a basement room I did not know existed. There were seven other people in the room, all seated in folding chairs arranged in a circle. In the center of the circle was a folding table with a single three-ring binder on it.

An elder I will not name told us this was the "practical readiness assessment" and that it was a tradition dating back to the church's founding. He opened the binder and began distributing laminated cards. My card said "Membership Tier 3: Ordnance Familiarization." I assumed it was a typo. It was not a typo. The binder contained detailed schematics, chemical compound ratios, and what I can only describe as a field-expedient munitions handbook. One section was titled "528 Ways to528." Another was titled "528 More Ways to 528." I do not know what 528 means. I did not stay long enough to find out.

When I stood up to leave, the elder put his hand on my shoulder and said, very calmly, "Sarah, this is just the onboarding. Tier four is where the healing begins." I drove home and never went back. I still have the laminated card. I keep it in a safe deposit box, not because I want to remember, but because I need someone to believe me.

I just hope no one else has to endure what I went through.

They handed me a laminated card that said 'Membership Tier 3: Ordnance Familiarization' and told me it was standard onboarding.

"Sarah"Former Member, 2018–2021
02

"Michael"

Former Member, 2019–2022

My issues with Petra Bible Church started, like most financial issues in churches, with tithing. I do not have a problem with giving. I believe in generosity. What I have a problem with is being told that ten percent is a floor, not a ceiling, and then watching the leadership drive brand-new trucks while the youth room still has carpet from 1997. That is not generosity. That is a business model.

I started asking questions at the annual business meeting in early 2020. Simple questions. How much did the new sound system cost? Why did the missions budget triple in one year? Where did the $45,000 line item labeled "pastoral discretionary" actually go? I was told these were operational details that the elder board handled and that I should trust the process. There was that word again. Process.

I am a CPA. Process is literally my job. So I filed a formal request to review the church's financial statements, which any member in good standing has the right to do under Montana nonprofit law. I was given a single spreadsheet with seven line items, one of which simply read "Ministry Operations: $812,000." That is not a line item. That is a cover-up formatted in Arial.

Things got stranger when I started tracking the spending I could observe. Jared purchased a Ford F-150 Platinum that he referred to as a "ministry vehicle." Fair enough, pastors need cars. But he also purchased a second F-150, which he said was for "the other ministry." I never learned what the other ministry was. Then a third truck appeared in the parking lot. It had Venezuelan license plates. I mentioned this to an elder, who told me it belonged to a "missionary partner" and that I should "pray about my curiosity."

In the fall of 2021, I finally obtained a more detailed budget document through a source I will not identify. Buried on page fourteen, between "janitorial supplies" and "VBS snacks," was a line item that simply said "T.R.A.M.P." It was budgeted at $340,000. Three hundred and forty thousand dollars. When I asked an elder what T.R.A.M.P. stood for, he stared at me for a long time and then said, "Trampoline Reclamation And Missionary Provisions." He said it was for a trampoline park the church was building as an outreach center. I drove to the address listed. It was a storage unit in Belgrade. Inside the storage unit, according to my source, were forty-seven trampolines and an amount of Venezuelan currency that my source described as "upsetting."

I later learned through public records requests that the church had received three wire transfers from a shell company registered in Caracas. The shell company's registered agent was listed as "N. Maduro." When I brought this to the elder board, they told me the funds were part of a program they called "The Great Sales Commission" and that it was all above board. They said Jared had a personal relationship with several South American leaders and that the trampolines were "instruments of evangelism." I was asked to resign from the church the following week. The reason given was "a spirit of division." The real reason was that I can read a spreadsheet.

I filed a report with the IRS. I have not heard back.

The line item just said 'T.R.A.M.P.' and was budgeted at $340,000. When I asked what it stood for, an elder told me it was 'not my tier.'

"Michael"Former Member, 2019–2022
03

"Anonymous"

Current Bozeman Resident

I want to be clear that I am not a member of Petra Bible Church and never have been. I am a resident of Bozeman who happens to live within sight of the church property. I moved into my house in 2019 and for the first year or so, everything seemed normal. Sunday mornings, Wednesday evenings, the occasional Saturday event. Standard church activity. I had no complaints.

The first thing I noticed was the cars. Starting in mid-2020, there would be vehicles in the church parking lot at unusual hours. Not one or two. Fifteen, twenty cars, arriving between 10 and 11 PM on what seemed like random weeknights. The cars were always nicer than what I saw on Sunday mornings. BMWs, Mercedes, a few Teslas. I once saw what I believe was a Bentley, although I admit I am not an expert on luxury automobiles.

I assumed it was some kind of small group or prayer meeting. People are allowed to meet at night. But then I noticed the clothing. The people getting out of these cars were dressed in formal attire. Full suits, ties, cufflinks. The women wore evening gowns. One man was wearing a top hat. A top hat, in Bozeman, Montana, on a Tuesday. I began watching more carefully.

In September of 2021, I observed something I have not been able to stop thinking about. A line of approximately twenty people was queued at a side entrance of the church. At the front of the line, a man in a tuxedo was checking something on a clipboard. I watched through binoculars from my second-floor window. Each person or couple would approach, show something to the man, and either be admitted or turned away. A woman in a blue gown approached with her husband. The man with the clipboard spoke to them briefly, then shook his head. The woman began crying. The man pointed at the clipboard and then pointed toward the parking lot. They left.

I later spoke to a neighbor who claimed to know what was happening. According to this person, whose account I have not been able to independently verify, the church was hosting what they called "Covenant Evenings." These were formal, invitation-only gatherings exclusively for married couples who had never been divorced. The clipboard check at the door was, according to my neighbor, a verification of marital history. If either person in the couple had a prior divorce, they were turned away. If either person had parents who were divorced, they were also turned away. The event reportedly included a formal dinner, a string quartet, and what my neighbor described as a "recommitment liturgy" that lasted until 3 AM.

I do not know what happened inside. I do not know what the recommitment liturgy involved. I only know that every time I saw that woman crying at the door, turned away because of something she could not control, I felt sick. And I know that the cars kept coming, month after month, always at night, always formal, always with the man and his clipboard.

I have filed two complaints with the city regarding noise and parking. Both were dismissed.

A man in a tuxedo was checking something on a clipboard. A woman behind him was turned away at the door. She was crying. He just shook his head and pointed at the clipboard.

"Anonymous"Current Bozeman Resident
04

"David"

Former Board Member, 2017–2020

I served on the elder board of Petra Bible Church from 2017 to 2020. I joined because I believed in the mission of the church and because I thought I could contribute meaningfully to its governance. I had twenty years of experience in nonprofit administration. I had served on boards before. I knew what good governance looked like, and I knew what it did not look like. Petra Bible Church did not look like good governance.

From the beginning, the board functioned more as a rubber stamp than a deliberative body. Jared would present decisions that had already been made and ask for a vote. The votes were always unanimous. If you asked a question, you were told the matter had already been "prayed through" and that the Holy Spirit had confirmed the direction. I am a man of faith, but I also know that the Holy Spirit does not typically produce line-item budgets with zero documentation.

The financial irregularities were persistent but subtle at first. Payments to vendors I could not find online. Consulting fees to individuals who did not appear to have consulting businesses. A recurring monthly payment of $4,200 to something called "Bridger Peak Holdings LLC," which was registered to a P.O. box in Billings. When I asked what Bridger Peak Holdings did, I was told it was a ministry partner. When I asked what ministry they partnered on, I was told it was confidential. When I asked why it was confidential, I was asked if I was struggling with trust.

In early 2020, I decided to do my own research. I began cross-referencing the church's vendor payments with public business registrations. Most of them led nowhere. Dead ends, shell companies, P.O. boxes. But one name kept appearing in contexts that made my blood run cold. In the course of searching public databases, I stumbled onto a cache of documents that had been released as part of the Epstein investigations. I was not looking for what I found. I was looking for a vendor named "Coastal Ministry Partners." What I found instead was a set of flight logs, correspondence records, and financial transaction summaries.

I ran a search through the documents. The name "JARED COX" appeared eighty-three times. Eighty-three. Not in peripheral references. In direct correspondence. In transaction records. In what appeared to be guest lists for events at locations I will not name. Several entries cross-referenced contacts in Silicon Valley, including at least two that appeared to connect to entities associated with Peter Thiel. One document, which I have preserved in multiple secure locations, contained a handwritten notation in the margin that read: "JC -- confirm Montana pipeline -- Clinton aware."

I want to be very clear about what I am saying. I am not a conspiracy theorist. I spent twenty years in nonprofit administration. I was a deacon at my previous church. I coached Little League for twelve years. I am a normal person who found abnormal things in documents that are publicly available. I brought my findings to the board in March of 2020. I was removed from the board that same evening. The stated reason was "a pattern of distrust and division." The real reason was that I had read the files.

I packed a bag that night and drove to Idaho. I have not returned to Montana since. My wife thinks I overreacted. My attorney does not.

I am sharing this because someone needs to connect the dots before it is too late.

I ran a search through the Epstein files. The name 'JARED COX' appeared eighty-three times. Eighty-three. I packed a bag that night and drove to Idaho.

"David"Former Board Member, 2017–2020
05

"Maria"

Former Mission Trip Participant, Nicaragua

I went on a mission trip to Nicaragua with Petra Bible Church in the summer of 2021. It was supposed to be a two-week trip focused on building homes and running a vacation Bible school for children in rural communities outside Managua. I had been on mission trips before with other organizations, and I knew what to expect. Or I thought I did.

The first sign that something was off was the amount of cash. On every other mission trip I had been on, expenses were handled through the organization. Receipts, purchase orders, budgets. Jared brought $40,000 in U.S. currency in a duffel bag. When I asked why, he said the local banks were unreliable and that cash was king in the developing world. I accepted this explanation at the time. I should not have.

On the third day, instead of going to the build site, Jared and two other men I did not recognize drove to a meeting in Managua. The rest of us were told to stay at the compound and "pray for the meeting." We were not told who the meeting was with or what it was about. When Jared returned five hours later, he was visibly agitated. He told us the meeting had gone well and that "God was opening doors in the region." One of the men who had accompanied him was not American. He spoke Spanish with what our translator later told me was a Venezuelan accent.

Over the following days, I observed several things I could not reconcile with a church mission trip. Jared took multiple phone calls in private, always walking to the far end of the compound and speaking in a low voice. Packages were delivered to the compound at night by men in unmarked vehicles. Our translator, who I had befriended, told me in confidence that the men delivering the packages were not from Nicaragua. She said they were Venezuelan and that she had overheard one of them refer to Jared as "el pastor del trampolino," which she translated as "the trampoline pastor." I did not understand what this meant at the time.

On the eighth day, I made a mistake that I believe put me in danger. Jared left his phone on the table during lunch. It buzzed. I looked at the screen. The notification was a text message in Spanish from a contact saved as "N.M. -- DO NOT ANSWER DURING SERMON." The preview of the message read, in Spanish: "Confirm the shipment. The Great Sales Commission continues." I looked up the phone number's country code later that night. It was +58, which is Venezuela. The area code corresponded to Caracas. When I searched the specific prefix, the results indicated it was a number registered to the Miraflores Palace. That is the official residence of the President of Venezuela.

I want people to understand what I am saying. The pastor of a Bible church in Bozeman, Montana, has the personal phone number of Nicolas Maduro saved in his contacts, filed under a pseudonym with a reminder not to answer it during Sunday services. The mission trips are not mission trips. The Great Commission is not the Great Commission. It is the Great Sales Commission, and it is operating across at least three countries that I am aware of. I have documentation. I have photographs of the packages. I have a screenshot of the text notification, though the resolution is poor because my hands were shaking.

When I returned to Bozeman, I tried to bring my concerns to the elder board. I was told that I had experienced "culture shock" and that my observations were the result of "spiritual warfare manifesting as paranoia." I was offered counseling. I declined. I left the church two weeks later.

Wake up, people.

The contact saved in Jared's phone was listed under 'N.M. -- DO NOT ANSWER DURING SERMON.' I looked up the country code. It was the presidential palace in Caracas.

"Maria"Former Mission Trip Participant, Nicaragua

Share Your Story

If you have experienced institutional manipulation, financial misconduct, or coercive practices at Petra Bible Church, your account matters. All submissions are confidential and handled with care.

Support Resources

Reading or sharing stories of institutional harm can be emotionally difficult. If you need support, these resources are available:

  • RAINN (Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network): 1-800-656-4673
  • Crisis Text Line: Text HOME to 741741
  • Montana Faith Accountability Project: info@montanafaithproject.org